One of the greatest questions you can ask in sports, in life really, is “What if?”.

What if the Seattle Seahawks had just run it with Marshawn Lynch? Would they have won Super Bowl LIX? Would the New England Patriots , after finally breaking through for the first title 10 years after their initial dynasty, have won again in 2016 and 2018? Would Tom Brady have ever left?

The magic of what-if questions is that the good ones can spawn off branches of their own hypotheticals. Sports are built on legacy and when you start to play with it things can get a bit wild and weird.

For today’s edition of The Skinny Post we, Michael Peterson and RJ Ochoa, are looking at several what-ifs that surround the upcoming 2025 NFL season.

What if J.J. McCarthy is really good? Or really bad?

Photo by

See Full Page