And Just Like That... fans may be split on several elements of the show — like Carrie and Aidan’s third-time’s-the-charm reunion, or the handling of Samantha’s absence. But there’s one thing the fandom can agree on: Carrie’s cat, Shoe, is perfect and must be protected at all costs.

That’s why the new season has some viewers nervous. Between Shoe’s escape from Carrie’s enormous abode, and an exterminator’s promise to use the “deadliest poison” available for Carrie’s rat problem, some fans are wondering whether And Just Like That might be foreshadowing a dangerous twist for the show’s most adorable cast member.

Justice For Carrie’s Cat

To recap: Che brought Shoe over to Carrie’s apartment in Season 2, and Carrie instantly fell in love and adopted the kitten. (Her name comes fro

See Full Page