Fourth Teen Charged In $100K Tarrytown Lighthouse Arson Spree In Westchester (UPDATE)

By Ben Crnic From Daily Voice

This story has been updated.

Four teens have been charged and a fourth is being sought after a weekend arson and vandalism spree caused heavy damage to the historic Tarrytown Lighthouse in Westchester County, police said.

The arrests were announced Friday, June 6, by Westchester County Police, who said two suspects—Elvin Ayavaca, 18, of White Plains, and Richard Barrero, 19, of Harrison—were arraigned in Sleepy Hollow Village Court.

Each is charged with three felonies: third-degree arson, third-degree burglary, and second-degree criminal mischief.

A third suspect, a 17-year-old whose name is being withheld due to his age, was arraigned in the Youth Part of Westchester County Court on the same charges. A fourth individual, age 17, was also caught and arrested on Friday evening. His name is also being withheld.

Authorities said the destruction was discovered around 9:40 a.m. Saturday, May 31, by a Westchester County Parks employee. The worker arrived at the lighthouse and saw smoke, broken windows, and signs of other serious damage, as Daily Voice previously reported.

The lighthouse, which sits along the Hudson River and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, sustained widespread destruction, including significant fire damage to the first-floor flooring, broken windows on both the first and second floors, destroyed antiques, furniture, and items of historical significance, and about 35 antique books ripped from shelves and strewn across the floor.

The damage at the Tarrytown Lighthouse included fire damage, broken windows, and destroyed items.

Westchester County Police Department

The Westchester County Parks Department is still assessing the full extent of the damage. An early estimate places the cost at approximately $100,000, but that figure may change, officials said. Public tours of the lighthouse have been suspended until further notice.

The four arrests follow the Westchester County Police Department's posting of surveillance images depicting the suspects on Tuesday, June 3.