A Toronto resident is advocating for greater accountability among members of Parliament regarding misinformation. Federico Sanchez has launched an electronic petition aimed at the House of Commons, proposing legislation that would require politicians to be more truthful in their public statements. The petition calls on federal lawmakers to introduce a bill to tackle the issue of misinformation presented by MPs to the public.
Sanchez's petition highlights the growing concern that misinformation poses a threat to democracy. It emphasizes the need for a mechanism to verify the statements made by MPs to maintain public trust in Canada's government. As of Tuesday, the petition had garnered over 8,700 signatures and will remain open until November 27. To be certified for presentation to the House, an e-petition must collect at least 500 signatures.
Sanchez, a physician who previously ran for political office as a Progressive Conservative in Ontario, stated that he does not aspire to be a politician. Instead, he aims to prevent Canada from following the United States' path, where he perceives a rise in political misinformation that undermines public trust. "We don’t have as bad a problem with misinformation coming from elected officials," he said. "But we are headed in that direction, if you ask me."
The petition draws inspiration from a proposed law in Wales that would disqualify politicians from office if they are found guilty of deliberate deception through an independent judicial process. A civil society group in Wales has suggested a model that would allow courts to issue a "correction notice" to politicians who make false or misleading statements. If the politician fails to correct the misinformation within seven days, the court could prevent them from holding office for a specified period.
This model aims to eliminate ambiguity by not requiring proof of intent and allows politicians the opportunity to correct misinformation without facing immediate sanctions. The Institute for Constitutional and Democratic Research, which proposed the model, believes it could serve as a framework for Canada.
However, some experts caution against the practicality of such measures. Alex Marland, a Canadian politics professor at Acadia University, noted that distinguishing truth from falsehood in politics can be complex. He pointed out that sometimes politicians may withhold information for the greater good. "The weird thing about politics is, sometimes, we can’t live in a world of complete purity," he said. "It’s a very messy field to be in."
Marland also argued that voters should ultimately decide who can serve in the legislature, rather than relying on appointed members of the judiciary. He suggested that more focus should be placed on regulating social media platforms that contribute to the spread of misinformation. "Why is it that somehow we give a free pass to the platforms online?" he asked. "If they’re the ones that are allowing deceit and lies to propagate, why is the focus not on them?"
The petition continues to gain traction as discussions about political accountability and misinformation remain at the forefront of public discourse.