October is more than just pumpkin spices and scary movies. Over at Hulu, it’s also about femme fatales, circus geeks and … Reese Witherspoon?!?

We’re not complaining. Watch With Us has curated three underrated Hulu movies for you to watch this weekend, and there’s nary a ghost or goblin in sight.

Ms. Witherspoon’s two movies on this list, How Do You Know and Water for Elephants, should appeal to those who want a good love story, while Nightmare Alley should satisfy fans of classy thrillers with all-star casts.

‘Nightmare Alley’ (2021)

It’s a bit odd to label Nightmare Alley, Guillermo del Toro’s twisted remake of the 1947 film noir classic, “underrated” when it was nominated for multiple Oscars — including Best Picture. But the critically acclaimed movie was a box office flop upon its

See Full Page