Jews around the world are expressing cautious optimism following the announcement of the return of hostages. This moment is seen as a glimmer of hope amid ongoing struggles. The sight of captives returning home is profoundly moving, symbolizing not just survival but the resilience of a people who refuse to be erased despite repeated attempts to undermine them.

While the return of the hostages is a cause for celebration, it is important to recognize that this does not equate to peace. Historical patterns suggest that such moments often lead to further tragedy rather than lasting resolution. The deal that facilitated the hostages' return is viewed as another instance of misguided optimism that has plagued Israel since the Oslo Accords. Critics argue that it reflects a flawed approach to dealing with terrorism, treating it as a grievance rather than an ideology that must be confronted.

The history of Israeli concessions, from the 1993 handshake on the White House lawn to the 2005 disengagement from Gaza, has often resulted in violence rather than peace. Each gesture of goodwill has been met with hostility, including suicide bombings and rocket attacks. The belief that Israel can achieve security through compromise has repeatedly proven to be a dangerous illusion.

As the current situation unfolds, there is concern that the return of hostages may be misinterpreted as a resolution to ongoing conflicts. Diplomatic efforts may be portrayed as a new beginning, but history serves as a reminder of the consequences of self-deception. Past attempts to appease adversaries have often led to further violence and loss.

Israel's adversaries have consistently made their intentions clear, expressing a desire for a world without Jews. Despite this, there remains a tendency to believe that these threats are not genuine. The Talmud warns that kindness towards the cruel can lead to harm for the innocent, a lesson that seems to be overlooked in contemporary discourse.

While it is appropriate to celebrate the safe return of hostages, it is crucial to remain vigilant. The ideology that has caused immense suffering has not been eradicated; it has merely paused. The conflict did not start on October 7, and it will not conclude with the current negotiations. It is an ongoing struggle against those who oppose the existence of a Jewish nation.

True peace will not emerge from agreements that require Israel to trust those who have consistently sought its destruction. The path to lasting peace lies not in diplomatic language but in a deeper understanding of the challenges faced by the Jewish people.