THE SCOOP Known for its sprawling waterfront and bustling Main Street, Bay Shore is a lively and popular locale.

"We have a theater; we have proximity to the hospital; we have Fire Island," said Town of Islip Councilman Michael McElwee. "It's a very unique hamlet that there's a lot going on in."

But in the early 2000s, much of Bay Shore's Main Street was vacant.

"There were three restaurants when I opened one," said McElwee, who owns The Penny Pub and Goody Two Shoes. "There's 31 now on Main Street."

In the past few years, blighted buildings were replaced by apartment complexes around the downtown area, most within walking distance of Main Street. Recently, Shoregate, a 418-unit development , opened in May 2024. A mixed-use, 156-apartment development, with 132 units designated for

See Full Page