Given that Spooky Season is in full swing, we decided to add some Halloween flavor to this week’s New England Patriots fan debate. Because just like everybody has a favorite horror movie, there are probably dozens of different answers to our question about…

Who is the scariest Patriots player of all time?

First a look at our staff debate, and then it’s on to your answers.

Pat Lane: Besides Aaron Hernandez?

Bernd Buchmasser: Should have added “(who did not murder people)” to the question.

Matthew Rewinski: It’s Rodney Harrison for me. One of his Chargers teammates said it best in Rodney’s A Football Life biopic: “You don’t go over the middle thinking, ‘I’m going to catch this ball first.’ You go over the middle thinking, ‘Where the hell is Rodney Harrison?’”

Brutally violent and equal

See Full Page