Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani are (once again) the latest American League and National League Most Valuable Player Award winners, and they're on a vaunted list that includes Ted Williams, Barry Bonds, Mickey Mantle and … Zoilo Versalles. But not all MVP seasons are treated equally. Some MVP seasons just happen to be the best that particular year, and some can stand among the best of all time.

Today, we come to you having completed a Herculean task: We come to rank every MVP season ever. Starting in 1931 -- the first year the Baseball Writers' Association of America voted on an award for both leagues -- we're looking at all 1891 MVP-winning seasons and pitting them against each other. We'll use a variety of ways to judge them, from Wins Above Replacement to historical import to the bac

See Full Page