May Court in Chagrin Falls is a legacy street. Howard Hanna realtor Barb Miller knows that firsthand. She’s selling 58 May Court , a 1923 build located just down the road from the home her father has inhabited since she was a child. The small-but-mighty blue house livens the neighborhood’s tradition with recent redesigns and a new price tag of $695,000.

“My parents bought their house in 1971 on that street for $26,000,” Miller quips.

The home at 58 May Court has been through a lot. Just a few decades ago, it was beige, and it had only two bathrooms. It had a deck, and its front porch was fully closed in.

Sign Up to Receive the Cleveland Magazine Daily Newsletter Six Days a Week

Now, the outside boasts a new attached garage and a new porch, and inside, you’ll find three bedrooms, thre

See Full Page