INDIANAPOLIS — Murder Sheet podcasters Kevin Greenlee, an attorney, and Aine Cain, a journalist, attended every court proceeding and read every legal filing in the case against Richard Allen, the man arrested in 2022 for the murders a half-decade earlier of Abby Williams and Libby German near the Monon High Bridge just outside of Delphi, Indiana.

Over the last five years, they’ve spoken on and off-the-record with nearly every significant participant in the proceedings and several tangential sources not necessarily with firsthand knowledge of the investigation but the experience to put the whole case in context.

They lined up well before dawn outside the Carroll County Courthouse for three weeks last fall to secure one of the limited and coveted seats in the courtroom.

Cain and Greenlee

See Full Page