FILE PHOTO: U.S. President Donald Trump laughs with U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent after asking him if he wants to be Fed Chair, at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., September 5, 2025. REUTERS/Brian Snyder/File Photo

In the 2024 election, the fact that Donald Trump's hardcore MAGA base aggressively supported him came as no surprise. But it was independents and swing voters who ultimately got Trump past the finish line and gave him a narrow victory in a close election.

Trump won the popular vote for the first time in 2024, defeating Democratic nominee Kamala Harris by roughly 1.5 percent — and the economy, according to polls, played a key role in that victory. Although the United States enjoyed record-low unemployment during Joe Biden's presidency, frustration over inflation worked to Trump's advantage.

But The New York Times' Jamelle Bouie, in his September 17 column, argues that Trump sold U.S. voters a "fantasy" that is now unravelling.

READ MORE: 'I'm the one asking the questions': CNN host cuts off Ted Cruz after he shouts over her

Trump, according to Bouie, told 2024 voters that "that there were no trade-offs" with the economy — and that Americans "could have their cake and eat it, too" when, "in reality," it "was a binary choice."

"The essence of President Trump's pitch to the American people last year was simple: They could have it both ways," Bouie explains. "They could have a powerful, revitalized economy and 'mass deportations now.' They could build new factories and take manufacturing jobs back from foreign competitors as well as expel every person who, in their view, didn't belong in the United States. They could live in a 'golden age' of plenty — and seal it away from others outside the country with a closed, hardened border."

One "binary choice," according to Bouie, was that "Americans could have a strong, growing economy, which requires immigration to bring in new people and fill demand for labor, or they could finance a deportation force and close the border to everyone but a small, select few."

"Millions of Americans embraced the fantasy," Bouie laments. "Now, about eight months into Trump's second term, the reality of the situation is inescapable. As promised, Trump launched a campaign of mass deportation. Our cities are crawling with masked federal agents, snatching anyone who looks 'illegal' to them — a bit of racial profiling that has, for now, been sanctioned by the Supreme Court. The jobs, however, haven't arrived."

READ MORE: 'Undisputed idiot king': Former NBC journalist calls Eric Trump 'the epitome of stupidity'

The New York Times columnist continues, "There are fewer manufacturing jobs than there were in 2024, thanks in part to the president's tariffs and, well, his immigration policies…. To embrace nativism in a global, connected economic world is to sacrifice prosperity for the sake of exclusion, just as the main effect of racial segregation in the American South was to leave the region impoverished and underdeveloped."

READ MORE: 'Didn't work for you': CNN analyst confronts Trump's favorite pundit on political violence

Jamelle Bouie's full New York Times column is available at this link (subscription required).