HBO Max has so many movies from the last 100 years of cinema that many of its older titles don’t have Rotten Tomatoes rankings simply because they predate that site by decades.

Regardless, HBO Max has several high-ranking Rotten Tomatoes films this month, including Warfare.

Since we’ve already put Warfare in the spotlight, Watch With Us is looking to the classics for the three new HBO Max movies with over 90 percent on Rotten Tomatoes.

All three of our picks are celebrating their anniversaries this year, including two very different crime dramas.

18 Must-Watch Thrillers on HBO Max Right Now (September 2025)

‘Dog Day Afternoon’ (1975)

Rotten Tomatoes rank: 96 percent

This month marks the 50th anniversary of Dog Day Afternoon, a crime drama by Sidney Lumet that’s loosely based on a re

See Full Page