As the fall weather starts to creep in, you might be in the mood to curl up on your couch for a scary movie night.

Netflix has plenty of horror flicks to choose from, but the amount of options can be overwhelming. How do you know which thrillers are worth the time — and the nightmares — and which are forgettable and derivative?

We’ve compiled the top 10 horror movies on Netflix in September 2025, according to their Rotten Tomatoes critic scores. Keep scrolling to see the list of frightening films.

#10: Creep

Rotten Tomatoes score: 91%

Release year: 2014

Mark Duplass stars as the eccentric Josef in this found footage psychological horror film that lives up to its title. Josef hires a videographer named Aaron (Patrick Brice) to document a day in his life, but Josef’s bizarre behavior

See Full Page