Christina Haack seems to have serious regrets about her third marriage to Josh Hall, and she’s revealing surprising information about his proposal to her.

Their engagement felt lightning-fast to fans, but it could have happened even sooner if Haack hadn’t stopped him. “The first time he proposed, I said no, and he threw the ring in the pool,” she told People. “That was probably red flag number one. I don’t think anyone’s ever heard that story before. Sorry. It’s true.”

Hall reportedly went all-out, decorating the pool area in anticipation of an affirmative response, but the HGTV star put the brakes on that big step.

“We weren’t getting along super great even then, off and on,” she added. “When things were good, they were good, but it just felt like I wasn’t quite ready, and so I just sa

See Full Page