Sophomore midfielder Molly Barneman scored the game-winning goal with 7:43 remaining in overtime to send Lacey to a dramatic 1-0 victory over Middletown North.
Senior goalie Tabytha Wedderman made seven saves for Lacey (2-6-1), which snapped a six-game losing streak with the win.
Emily Montalto-Zadroga made seven saves for Middletown North (3-6).