Welcome to Part 1 of OTM’s 2025 Red Sox postmortem. Today, we kick off the series by looking at our favorite — and least favorite — moments and players of the season. Check back in for further installments covering management, awards, and offseason needs.

What was your favorite moment of the 2025 Red Sox season?

The Red Sox lost the game, but watching Payton Tolle’s debut in Fenway was the first time in a long time that I felt like people really noticed what was going on. This isn’t a prospect who was hyped up as the next big thing for two years before finally being promoted. He was a kid who came out of nowhere, and there was a legitimate buzz in the stadium before the game. He came out and dominated, but it was a fun night nonetheless.

— Jacob Roy

I suppose when they clinched that pl

See Full Page