Long Island Railroad employees implicated in a years-long fake ID scam made upwards of three-times the overtime pay of their honest colleagues — with one foreman even walking away with more than the train line’s president was paid in a year.

The three-dozen employees accused in the scam made an average of 1.3 and 2.7 times the overtime pay of their colleagues in 2024, an analysis from Newsday found .

And some even made more — including gang foreman Craig Murray, who allegedly raked in $220,073 in overtime last year.

At least three-dozen LIRR employees were implicated in the years-long scam. Michael Nagle

With his $124,361 salary, Murray made $345,779 in 2024. That’s more than the LIRR’s president makes in a year, according to Newsday.

The scam saw at least 36 LIRR workers use fak

See Full Page