In an era where the New York Yankees haven’t experienced a losing season since 1992, a philosophical debate has emerged about the direction of baseball’s most storied franchise.

At the center of this discussion is the contrast between Hal Steinbrenner’s measured approach to team building and the win-at-all-costs mentality that defined his father George’s tenure.

The younger Steinbrenner’s philosophy, which has been marked by consistent contention over championship-or-bust seasons, has drawn both praise for stability and criticism for complacency.

This tension has become particularly pointed as superstar Aaron Judge continues his prime years without a World Series ring.

“The person who doesn’t believe in the Steinbrenner doctrine is Hal Steinbrenner, the son,” ESPN MLB insider Buster

See Full Page