Plan A for the Phillies is to bring back J.T. Realmuto, who is a free agent and will turn 35 before next season.

Relative to the rest of the league's catchers, Realmuto remains among the best, despite his wear and tear (no one caught more innings in 2025). One might imagine it's the years, not the dollars, that the Phils' front office will be worried about — a drop-off is inevitable in his production and health.

But there is a history of catchers playing well into their late 30s, and it seems like Realmuto could be one of those guys.

Another team could make a huge offer — he's a free agent, after all — and the Phillies need to have a contingency plan.

The problem is, the options just aren't there. There is no upgrade for Realmuto ,and there are few everyday options even available on th

See Full Page