This winter features what just might be the most divisive case we’ve seen for a free agent in years.

We’re talking about Luis Arraez , who is either “the best contact hitter alive” or “a below-average baseball player,” with little middle ground. You might think he’s a superstar. You also might not think he’s worth a roster spot. It’s shockingly easy to argue either side of that.

The truth, as always, is somewhere in between, though. But where, exactly? How many teams might be interested in this, let’s say, very particular set of skills – and which teams might fit? As he reaches free agency for the first time, we'll finally get to see how all 30 teams value this type of player.

Arraez, 29 in April, just set career lows in batting average (.292) and OPS+ (99, or just a tick below le

See Full Page