The bullpen for the New York Yankees certainly had its ups and downs through the 2025 regular season. When it came to the starting rotation, they performed about as well as manager Aaron Boone or any of the Yankees faithful could have asked for. They finished eighth in MLB in fWAR and fourth in ERA. However, the bullpen was on the opposite side of the spectrum.

Through the 162-game regular season, the Yankees’ bullpen finished 21st in fWAR and 23rd in ERA, and it wasn’t strange to see headlines that the bullpen had blown another game.

While not everyone in the bullpen was equally at fault for losing the team games, there were, of course, players who were common denominators, including a pitcher who just signed with the crosstown rival New York Mets: Devin Williams.

2025 Statistics: 67 g

See Full Page