In 2003, the directors of Dumb and Dumber and There’s Something About Mary, Peter and Bobby Farrelly, released Stuck on You. The movie starred Matt Damon and Greg Kinnear as a pair of conjoined twins who run a burger joint in Martha’s Vineyard. Damon’s character, Bob, is content with living a low-key life even though Kinnear’s character, Walt, has big dreams of becoming a famous actor. Stuck on You wasn’t as big a hit as the Farrellys’ earlier movies, but if they’d gotten their original choices for the lead roles, that might’ve ended up being a totally different story.

As early as 1999, TIME magazine reported that Woody Allen would star in the movie. When Stuck on You was released four years later without the famous comedian in the lead, Bobby Farrelly said that things hadn’t worked out w

See Full Page