News

'I Ate 4 Boxes' - Aldi Shoppers Can't Get Enough Of These Peppermint Cookies By Alexandra Fay Dec. 8, 2025 12:20 pm EST

Holiday treats come and go, but Aldi shoppers have declared a seasonal winner with the kind of intensity usually reserved for Costco holiday foods , must-buy Aldi items, and Trader Joe's fan-favorite staples. Returning to Aldi shelves once again, Benton's Fudge Covered Peppermint Cremes — chocolate fudge-dipped sandwich cookies dusted with crushed peppermint candy — have developed a cult following deep enough to crash shopping carts and test self-control.

Reddit has basically become an addiction support group for the cookies. On an r/aldi subreddit , one shopper confessed, "I was hoping they'd discontinue these. I ate four boxes over the holidays,

See Full Page