“Iconic” is an adjective thrown around far too casually in 2025, but when it comes to sweet treats , few embody that word quite like Oreo and Reese’s . The sandwich cookie and peanut buttercup are a category onto themselves, and we have these two… dare we say, “iconic” snacks to thank (or blame) for that.

Both Reese’s and Oreo experiment with new flavors and product offerings on a constant churn, but the melding of the two is not something we had anticipated.

So when we were offered an early sampling, we were game to give the products a spin. And of course we ranked them, because at the end of the day you’re probably only going to buy one of these. So we did it for you! Not because we’re totally obsessed with cookies or anything. Anyway, let’s dive in.

3. Oreo Reese’s Peanut Butte

See Full Page